Active
Sale
Retail
Convenience Store
Street Retail
ID 06ada8ab
2021 S Reynolds Rd
2021 S Reynolds Rd, Toledo, OH 43614
For Sale
$1,952,980$89.95/SF
- Building Size
- 21,712 SF
- Lot Size
- 1.92 ac
- County
- Lucas
- Listed
- 06/10/2026
- Updated
- 06/10/2026

1 / 4
Overview
Discover the vibrant, bustling community surrounding the property in Toledo, OH. The area is home to a variety of retail and dining establishments, providing a desirable destination for both locals and visitors. Within close proximity, the Franklin Park Mall offers a diverse mix of retailers, attracting a steady flow of shoppers. Popular local attractions, such as the Toledo Museum of Art and the Toledo Zoo, provide additional draws to the area, contributing to a lively and dynamic atmosphere. The location's convenient access to major roadways ensures strong visibility and accessibility, making it an ideal investment opportunity for retail and street retail investors.
- Attractive Yield: Offered at a 7.75% cap rate with ~$151K NOI, providing strong in-place cash flow
- Corporate-Backed Tenant: Lease guaranteed by Goodwill, a nationally recognized operator with over 4,000 locations and $7B+ in revenue
- Recession-Resilient Use: Essential, needs-based retail with consistent traffic driven by donation and resale model
- Minimal Landlord Responsibilities: NN lease structure with tenant covering majority of expenses, reducing ownership burden
- Strong Real Estate Fundamentals: 21,712 SF building on 1.92 acres with ample parking and functional layout
- High Visibility Location: Positioned on a heavily trafficked corridor with excellent frontage and accessibility
- Value-Add Potential: Below replacement cost (~$90/SF) with future repositioning or redevelopment upside
- Dense Retail Corridor: Surrounded by national retailers and strong consumer traffic drivers. (see aerials on pages 5–6)
- Accessible Midwest Market: Located in Toledo with a population of ~170K within 5 miles and solid household incomes
Attachments
Additional Information
- City
- Toledo
- State
- OH
- Zip Code
- 43614
- Secondary Uses
- Convenience Store, Street Retail
- Zoning
- CR
- Zoning Desc.
- Regional Commercial
- Tenant
- Goodwill
- Call For Offers
- Yes
- # of Buildings
- 1
- Year Built
- 1972
- Rentable SF
- 21,712
- Tenancy
- Single Tenant
- Vehicles Per Day
- 32,600 VPD
- Avg. Occupancy
- 100%
- Parcel APN
- 2001847
- Listing ID
- 06ada8ab
- City
- Toledo
- State
- OH
- Zip Code
- 43614
- Secondary Uses
- Convenience Store, Street Retail
- Zoning
- CR
- Zoning Desc.
- Regional Commercial
- Tenant
- Goodwill
- Call For Offers
- Yes
- # of Buildings
- 1
- Year Built
- 1972
- Rentable SF
- 21,712
- Tenancy
- Single Tenant
- Vehicles Per Day
- 32,600 VPD
- Avg. Occupancy
- 100%
- Parcel APN
- 2001847
- Listing ID
- 06ada8ab
